← All errata
Housing Element✓ Verified against codeNovember 22, 2026

Dos Palos: A Compliant Draft, Still a Notice of Violation

HCD said the draft met its content rules in 2025, but the rezones hinge on an annexation stalled to 2027 - and two grants went unused.

You're weighing a project in Dos Palos, out in Merced County, and the City tells you its housing element is handled — the latest draft cleared HCD's content review back in 2025. So the Builder's Remedy is off the table and your by-right leverage is gone, right?

Not according to HCD.

A "finished" draft still drew a Notice of Violation

On August 10, 2026, HCD's Housing Accountability Unit sent the City of Dos Palos a Notice of Violation. HCD's position is not that the draft was badly written — it's the opposite. HCD had already found, in its November 24, 2025 findings letter, that the draft "met the statutory requirements described in HCD's October 24, 2025 review."

But meeting the content requirements of Housing Element Law (Gov. Code § 65583) on paper is not the same as substantial compliance. HCD drew the line plainly: "the housing element cannot be found in substantial compliance until the City has completed and submitted the necessary rezones."

Verified against HCD's Notice of Violation to the City of Dos Palos (Housing Accountability Unit), dated August 10, 2026.

Here's the thing: the rezones are the deal

Here's the thing: a housing element's text is only half the job. The rezones are what turn an inventory into real capacity — and in Dos Palos those rezones depend on an annexation. By the City's own timeline, HCD wrote, the annexation necessary to implement rezones would not be completed until late 2026 or early 2027.

That delay is what HCD rested the violation on:

"the City's proposed date of December 2026 or early 2027, for completion of annexation and adoption of its rezone ordinance is unsatisfactory."

The 6th-cycle housing element was due January 31, 2024 (Gov. Code § 65588). Pushing rezone adoption to 2027 would, in HCD's words, delay a compliance determination until "nearly three years past its statutory due date." Acting under Government Code § 65585, HCD found: "the City has failed to adopt a substantially compliant housing element and is therefore in violation of state law."

That is HCD's enforcement position — not a court judgment (more on that below).

Why a planner or builder should care

HCD's letter spells out the stakes of an element that stays out of compliance:

  • The Builder's Remedy applies. HCD wrote that "jurisdictions that do not have a substantially compliant housing element are subject to the Builder's Remedy" under the Housing Accountability Act (Gov. Code § 65589.5). For a qualifying affordable or mixed-income project, that can strip a city's ability to deny it solely for inconsistency with zoning or the general plan.
  • State funding stalls. HCD lists programs for which noncompliance means ineligibility or delay — the Permanent Local Housing Allocation, the Local Housing Trust Fund, Infill Infrastructure Grants, and more.
  • Penalties escalate. HCD flags court-imposed fines starting at "a minimum fine of $10,000 per month, up to $100,000 per month," multipliers of three and then six for continued noncompliance, and possible appointment of a receiver.
  • An AG referral is on the table. HCD may refer the matter to the California Office of the Attorney General.

The grants Dos Palos left on the table

The letter also documents help the City didn't use. HCD noted the City "was eligible for but did not apply for a grant through the SB 2 Program," and that it "was also eligible for $150,000 through the Local Early Action Planning Grant (LEAP) for local planning activities but withdrew from the grant without expending funds." If you're a resident or developer wondering why a small city's rezones are years behind, that is part of the paper trail.

What this means if you're the one building

The takeaway for practitioners: a city telling you its housing element is "done" is not the end of the inquiry. If the rezones aren't adopted and approved by HCD, HCD's position is that the city is not in substantial compliance — and the by-right leverage that comes with noncompliance may still be live.

One hard caveat: an HCD Notice of Violation is HCD's interpretive position, not settled law. Courts are the final arbiter of whether a jurisdiction is in compliance, and only a housing-element decertification self-executes. Before you act on any of this, verify the City's current compliance status with the jurisdiction and confirm your options with qualified land-use counsel. Nothing here is legal advice.

What CrossBeam does with it

When the letter lands on your desk, CrossBeam turns it around the same day: what each item is actually asking, the code or law behind it, and a written response you can hand to your team or your attorney — the back-and-forth that used to eat weeks, done in a couple of hours.