The First Four SB 79 Opt-Outs HCD Has Signed Off On
Industrial hubs, sites already at 50% of SB 79, an unwalkable path, local landmarks — four approvals, each with a revoke clause.
You own a parcel near a Bay Area train station, and the question is simple: does SB 79 reach it, or did your city pull it back out? California's transit-oriented development law went live July 1, 2026, letting housing rise near major transit on sites local zoning never allowed. But SB 79 also lets a city exempt or temporarily exclude certain sites by ordinance, subject to HCD review.
Here's the thing: HCD has started signing off. Its first substantial-compliance letters show which carve-outs have cleared review — and the exact ground each one rode in on.
One caution up front: a substantial-compliance letter is HCD's determination, not a court ruling. HCD found these ordinances meet SB 79's requirements; it did not bless the carve-outs as settled law. And every one of these approvals reserves HCD's right to revoke.
Verified against HCD's SB 79 Ordinance/Alternative Plan Findings letters to San José (June 4, 2026), San Carlos (June 19, 2026), Campbell (June 30, 2026), and San Francisco (July 1, 2026).
San José: industrial employment hubs
San José enacted Ordinance No. 31316, adding Chapter 20.197 to its zoning code to exempt designated industrial employment hubs. HCD's conclusion:
"HCD finds that all the requirements have been met for adopting an ordinance to designate industrial employment hubs exempt from the provisions of SB 79."
The grounds, per HCD: each hub is "a contiguous area of at least 250 acres" designated as an employment lands area in the Envision San José 2040 General Plan, "primarily dedicated to industrial use" as defined in Government Code § 65912.121(f)(3), where "housing is not permitted or conditionally permitted." HCD issued its findings under § 65912.160(d)(3)(A).
San Carlos: already zoned at half of SB 79
San Carlos (Ordinance 1634) took a different path near its Caltrain station, temporarily excluding parcels that already allow dense housing. HCD accepted that each excluded site "already permits developments (in terms of density and residential floor area ratio) at no less than 50 percent of the standards specified under subdivision (a) of Government Code Section 65912.157" — the temporary-exclusion ground in § 65912.161(b)(1)(A). This one is temporary — it holds only because the local zoning is already close to what SB 79 requires.
Campbell: too far to walk, and local landmarks
Campbell (Ordinance 26-2350) cleared two carve-outs. The first turns on walking distance. A parcel can sit within half a mile of a transit stop and still be excluded if, as HCD put it, "The properties identified in the Ordinance lack a walking path of less than one mile to a pedestrian access point of a qualifying transit-oriented development stop" — the exclusion in § 65912.160(e)(1). Straight-line proximity isn't the test; the actual walk is.
The second is historic. Campbell temporarily excluded sites "designated on the City of Campbell's local historic register as of January 1, 2025," under § 65912.161(b)(1)(F) — and only until one year after the city adopts its seventh housing-element revision.
San Francisco: hubs, low-resource areas, and a plan — with a string
San Francisco (Ordinance 082-26) got the most sweeping approval: a full TOD alternative plan. HCD found the city's ordinance and plan "address the statutory requirements for a TOD alternative plan under Government Code section 65912.161, subdivision (a); industrial employment hubs under Government Code section 65912.160, subdivision (e)(2); and the capacity and low-resource area requirements under Government Code section 65912.161, subdivision (b)."
But the finding came with a condition. HCD determined that one subsection — Planning Code § 207.11(b)(5) — "impermissibly prohibits the use of the State Density Bonus Law for qualifying housing development projects on applicable alternative plan sites," and made its compliance finding "contingent on the City not enforcing" it — approval only so long as the city drops that one provision.
What this means for your parcel
Two things carry across these letters. First, HCD reserved the right to revoke every one of these findings. Second, three of the four (San Carlos, Campbell, and San Francisco) add that the Metropolitan Transportation Commission's SB 79 map carries a "rebuttable presumption of validity," and the city's own map "should be at least as inclusive" as it — so a carve-out that undercuts MTC's map is on borrowed time.
If an ordinance tells you your site is exempt, read the ground it claims — a 250-acre industrial hub, a half-of-SB-79 zone, an unwalkable path, a local landmark — and check whether your parcel fits it. These are HCD's determinations, not court rulings, and SB 79 is new enough that none of this has been tested in litigation. Verify with your jurisdiction and your own counsel before you rely on any of it. None of this is legal advice.
What CrossBeam does with it
When the letter lands on your desk, CrossBeam turns it around the same day: what each item is actually asking, the code or law behind it, and a written response you can hand to your team or your attorney — the back-and-forth that used to eat weeks, done in a couple of hours.